| Score | NO | Player | Fixture | Season |
| 207 | * | V.S. Carter | Guisborough v Saltburn | 1937 |
| 183 | | N. Schneider | Marton v Castle Eden | 1992 |
| 182 | | R. Smith | Thornaby v Saltburn | 1947 |
| 177 | | A.J. Graham | Seaton Carew v Thornaby | 1909 |
| 176 | | P.N. Jackson | Middlesbrough v Nunthorpe | 1992 |
| 174 | | B. Lee | Hartlepool v North Ormesby | 1909 |
| 173 | * | C. Westwood | Saltburn v Stockton | 1979 |
| 168 | | R. Wilson | Middlesbrough v Castle Eden | 1966 |
| 162 | | M. Hall | Darlington v Saltburn | 1932 |
| 161 | | H. French | Marton v Middlesbrough | 1955 |
| 160 | | C. Bell | Castle Eden v Darlington RA | 1969 |
| 159 | | A.J. Graham | Seaton Carew v Saltburn | 1911 |
| 158 | | G.B. Winney | Marton v West Hartlepool | 1935 |
| 157 | | P. Willey | Richmondshire v Hartlepool | 1990 |
| 154 | * | R. Marden | Barnard Castle v Seaton Carew | 1984 |
| 152 | * | C.R. Knaggs | Marton v Saltburn | 1928 |
| 151 | * | C. Blackburn | Richmondshire v Bishop Auckland | 1982 |
| 150 | | W. Simpson | West Hartlepool v Marton | 1928 |
| 150 | * | B. Lamb | Castle Eden v Redcar | 1973 |
| 150 | | R. Wilson | Middlesbrough v Yarm | 1977 |