| Club | Highest | Lowest |
| Barnard Castle | 265-3 v Saltburn (1963) | 33 v Seaton Carew (1973) |
| Billingham Synthonia | 290-4 v Blackhall (1938) | 15 v Yarm (1987) |
| Bishop Auckland | 295 v Great Ayton (1939) | 15 v Great Ayton (1955) |
| Blackhall | 283-5 v Normanby Hall (1938) | 15 v Thornaby (1973) |
| Castle Eden | 258-1 v Darlington (1992) | 20 v Darlington (1976) |
| Darlington | 361-4 v Thornaby (1906) | 17 v Guisborough (1947) |
| Darlington RA | 288 v Guisborough (1923) | 13 v Middlesbrough (1924) |
| Dormans | 196-8 v Billingham Synthonia (1945) | 23 v Summersons (1944) |
| Great Ayton | 271-4 v Stockton (1980) | 26 v Marton (1962) |
| Great Ayton | | 26 v Preston (1946) |
| Guisborough | 305-2 v Saltburn (1937) | 7 v West Hartlepool (1902) |
| Hartlepool | 260-2 v Norton (1990) | 22 v Marton (1967) |
| Hartlepool | | 22 v Redcar (1920) |
| Mainsforth | 210-6 v Dormans (1945) | 51 v Preston (1945) |
| Marske | 285-7 v Great Ayton (1990) | 17 v Northallerton (1963) |
| Marton | 334-6 v West Hartlepool (1936) | 12 v Great Ayton (1972) |
| Middlesbrough | 320-2 v Nunthorpe (1992) | 9 v Stockton (1898) |
| Normanby Hall | 272-8 v Stockton (1964) | 15 v Norton (1930) |
| North Ormesby | 242 v Stockton (1910) | 11 v Norton (1906) |
| Northallerton | 266-5 v Blackhall (1990) | 44 v Marske (1965) |
| Norton | 304-2 v Marton (1949) | 15 v Preston (1941) |
| Nunthorpe | 240-1 v Normanby Hall (1990) | 48 v Richmondshire (1984) |
| Preston | 297-5 v Thornaby (1913) | 5 v North Ormesby (1909) |
| Redcar | 304-8 v Middlesbrough (1897) | 11 v Thornaby (1937) |
| Richmondshire | 256-3 v Barnard Castle (1982) | 68 v Barnard Castle (1984) |
| Saltburn | 270 v Redcar (1926) | 17 v Guisborough (1937) |
| Seaton Carew | 286-6 v Thornaby v (1909) | 34 v West Hartlepool (1935) |
| Stockton | 308-7 v Norton (1905) | 19 v Yarm (1937) |
| Stockton | | 19 v Great Ayton (1978) |
| Stokesley | 249-2 v Barnard Castle (1984) | 29 v Marske (1963) |
| Summersons | 197-8 v Darlington (1944) | 33 v West Hartlepool (1943) |
| Thornaby | 279-8 v Guisborough (1923) | 17 v West Hartlepool (1910) |
| Yarm | 276-9 v Marton (1949) | 15 v Bishop Auckland (1935) |