| Season | Player | Fixture |
| 1903 | T. Smith | West Hartlepool v Middlesbrough |
| 1910 | J.H. Hall | Saltburn v Middlesbrough |
| 1913 | C.P. Barrowcliffe | Stockton v Bishop Auckland |
| 1922 | C.P. Barrowcliffe | Stockton v Darlington |
| 1941 | H. Pratt | Darlington v Blackhall |
| 1944 | H. Pratt | Darlington v Norton |
| 1954 | G. Christon | Middlesbrough v West Hartlepool |
| 1961 | J.B. Hodgson | v Darlington |