| Runs | Fixture | Season |
| 9 | Redcar v Norton | 1941 |
| 11 | North Ormesby v Darlington | 1901 |
| 11 | Thornaby v West Hartlepool | 1925 |
| 12 | Middlesbrough v Stockton | 1908 |
| 12 | Normanby Hall v Redcar | 1931 |
| 14 | Darlington RA v Darlington | 1926 |
| 14 | West Hartlepool v Redcar | 1947 |
| 14 | Synthonia v Norton | 1966 |
| 15 | Middlesbrough v West Hartlepool | 1905 |
| 16 | Thornaby v Redcar | 1899 |
| 16 | Redcar v West Hartlepool | 1901 |
| 16 | West Hartlepool v Saltburn | 1912 |
| 16 | Blackhall v Thornaby | 1943 |
| 17 | Redcar v Norton | 1944 |
| 17 | Synthonia v Redcar | 1953 |
| 17 | Darlington v Middlesbrough | 1958 |
| 18 | Ironopolis v Guisborough | 1895 |
| 18 | Thornaby v Saltburn | 1911 |
| 18 | Synthonia v Guisborough | 1944 |
| 19 | Guisborough v Norton | 1910 |
| 19 | Guisborough v Norton | 1914 |
| 19 | Yarm v Darlington | 1942 |
| 19 | Redcar v Darlington | 1945 |
| 19 | Stockton v Darlington | 1952 |
| 20 | Redcar v Stockton | 1898 |
| 20 | Saltburn v Norton | 1936 |
| 20 | Preston v Stockton | 1940 |
| 20 | Saltburn v Synthonia | 1945 |
| 21 | North Ormesby v Guisborough | 1896 |
| 21 | Middlesbrough v Blackhall | 1933 |
| 21 | Blackhall v Preston | 1942 |
| 21 | Normanby Hall v Guisborough | 1965 |
| 22 | Normanby Hall v Redcar | 1927 |
| 22 | Yarm v Bishop Auckland | 1940 |
| 22 | Darlington v Saltburn | 1948 |
| 22 | Blackhall v Bishop Auckland | 1958 |
| 22 | Middlesbrough v Guisborough | 1966 |
| 23 | West Hartlepool v Darlington | 1914 |
| 23 | Darlington RA v Norton | 1930 |
| 23 | Marton v Blackhall | 1940 |
| 23 | Norton v Saltburn | 1971 |
| 24 | Middlesbrough v North Ormesby | 1908 |
| 24 | Thornaby v Redcar | 1913 |
| 24 | West Hartlepool v Darlington RA | 1920 |
| 24 | Guisborough v Bishop Auckland | 1923 |
| 24 | Normanby Hall v Thornaby | 1924 |
| 24 | Bishop Auckland v West Hartlepool | 1932 |
| 24 | Bishop Auckland v Blackhall | 1936 |
| 24 | Redcar v Bishop Auckland | 1937 |
| 24 | Stockton v Bishop Auckland | 1938 |
| 24 | Norton v Guisborough | 1941 |
| 24 | Norton v Thornaby | 1942 |
| 24 | Guisborough v Norton | 1943 |
| 24 | Middlesbrough v Norton | 1943 |
| 24 | Synthonia v Thornaby | 1970 |
| 25 | Ironopolis v Redcar | 1895 |
| 25 | Middlesbrough v Stockton | 1904 |
| 25 | Thornaby v Guisborough | 1907 |
| 25 | Thornaby v West Hartlepool | 1919 |
| 25 | Blackhall v Synthonia | 1938 |
| 25 | Redcar v Thornaby | 1942 |
| 25 | Redcar v West Hartlepool | 1944 |
| 25 | Saltburn v Darlington | 1948 |
| 25 | Synthonia v Normanby Hall | 1948 |
| 25 | Middlesbrough v Norton | 1965 |
| 25 | Darlington v Saltburn | 2000 |
| 26 | North Ormesby v Middlesbrough | 1896 |
| 26 | Middlesbrough v Guisborough | 1919 |
| 26 | Middlesbrough v Stockton | 1920 |
| 26 | Bishop Auckland v Redcar | 1924 |
| 26 | Saltburn v West Hartlepool | 1936 |
| 26 | Great Ayton v Normanby Hall | 1940 |
| 26 | Preston v Middlesbrough | 1942 |
| 26 | Darlington v Normanby Hall | 1943 |
| 26 | Synthonia v Darlington | 1956 |
| 27 | Thirsk v Redcar | 1893 |
| 27 | Thirsk v Guisborough | 1895 |
| 27 | Guisborough v West Hartlepool | 1902 |
| 27 | Darlington v Norton | 1928 |
| 27 | Synthonia v Thornaby | 1945 |
| 27 | Saltburn v Normanby Hall | 1946 |
| 27 | Stockton v Middlesbrough | 1948 |
| 27 | Blackhall v Middlesbrough | 1954 |
| 27 | Blackhall v Stockton | 1965 |
| 28 | Thornaby v Guisborough | 1914 |
| 28 | Saltburn v West Hartlepool | 1924 |
| 28 | Norton v Darlington | 1928 |
| 28 | Yarm v Thornaby | 1942 |
| 28 | Preston v Darlington | 1942 |
| 28 | Guisborough v West Hartlepool | 1957 |
| 28 | Normanby Hall v Bishop Auckland | 1959 |
| 29 | Stockton v Saltburn | 1907 |
| 29 | Redcar v Stockton | 1920 |
| 29 | Guisborough v Redcar | 1921 |
| 29 | Bishop Auckland v Stockton | 1934 |
| 29 | Redcar v Darlington RA | 1946 |
| 29 | Normanby Hall v Thornaby | 1953 |
| 29 | Thornaby v Middlesbrough | 1962 |
| 29 | Saltburn v Marske | 1972 |