| Score | Fixture | Season |
| 372-4 | Marske v Bishop Auckland | 2011 |
| 365-2 | Marske v Hartlepool | 2016 |
| 349-6 | Guisborough v Saltburn | 1906 |
| 342-4 | Marske v Great Ayton | 2016 |
| 331-3 | Redcar v Darlington | 1992 |
| 328-4 | Redcar v Northallerton | 1990 |
| 323-6 | Norton v Guisborough | 1903 |
| 323-7 | West Hartlepool v Redcar | 1910 |
| 322-2 | Richmondshire v Guisborough | 2013 |
| 317-4 | Richmondshire v Thornaby (dec) | 2013 |
| 315-7 | West Hartlepool v Saltburn | 1934 |
| 313-6 | Darlington v Stockton | 1932 |
| 313-7 | Redcar v Saltburn | 1908 |
| 313-7 | Barnard Castle v Hartlepool | 2016 |
| 312-6 | Bishop Auckland v Thornaby | 1906 |
| 311-3 | Marske v Darlington RA | 2002 |
| 310-2 | Darlington v Middlesbrough | 1905 |
| 310-5 | Redcar v West Hartlepool | 1920 |
| 310-5 | Hartlepool v Darlington RA | 2003 |
| 310-7 | Richmondshire v Sedgefield | 2013 |
| 309-2 | Marske v Guisborough | 2007 |
| 308-4 | Darlington v Richmondshire | 2002 |
| 308-5 | Richmondshire v Marton | 2011 |
| 308-6 | Hartlepool v Great Ayton | 2016 |
| 308-10 | Norton v Guisborough | 1924 |
| 307-7 | Hartlepool v Norton | 2016 |
| 306-4 | Guisborough v Redcar | 1905 |
| 305-5 | Middlesbrough v North Ormesby | 1906 |
| 305-5 | Marske v Saltburn | 2006 |
| 305-6 | Middlesbrough v Stockton | 1978 |
| 303-5 | Stockton v Normanby Hall | 1925 |
| 302-3 | Richmondshire v Darlington (dec) | 1995 |
| 302-6 | West Hartlepool v Guisborough | 1928 |
| 301-2 | Marske v Blackhall | 1999 |
| 301-4 | Richmondshire v Markse | 2009 |
| 301-5 | West Hartlepool v Thornaby | 1913 |
| 300-2 | Barnard Castle v Middlesbrough | 2016 |
| 300-6 | Darlington v Thornaby | 1906 |
| 300-6 | Blackhall v Bishop Auckland | 1933 |
| 300-8 | Normanby Hall v Guisborough | 1924 |
| 300-9 | Guisborough v Norton | 1911 |